what i need to do to bring my pies up to scratch:
- get that gorgeous tender yet crispy/flaky crust that Barbara gets
- not overcook the filling (so the apples are mushy) :(
start with making your own crust as it is really worth it (recipes below). my crust isn't quite there yet, but the flavour beats store bought crusts hands down.
to fill the apple pie (in a larger deep pie plate):
- line the pie plate with pie dough (you will need a sheet of it for the top)
- 6 northern spy apples (7 if they are smaller)
- brown sugar: to taste
- butter: about 6 small cubes of it
- more brown sugar
- cinnamon (my mom hates it, so i lie to her and put a little in. she won't read this blog, so don't tell her)
- sprinkle a few tablespoons of brown sugar in the bottom of the pie dough. you CAN sprinkle a bit of flour on the bottom of the pie dough before you add the sugar. i think this is to keep the bottom of the pie crust from getting mucky.
- peel and core the apples and slice then into medium thick slices. don't worry too much, it doesn't seem to matter too much how thick/thin they are or how neat/messy. i cut the slices off the peeled un-cored apple right into the pie dish.
- when you've got a big mound of apple slices in there, you're almost done. sprinkle a few more tablespoons of sugar on the top of the apples, and then dot the top of the pie with the butter cubes. too much sugar and butter will overwhelm your apples. Norther Spys are beautifully tart! -sprinkle cinnamon on top if you like cinnamon - i usually do.
- cover the pie with the second sheet of pastry... firmly pinch around the edges to seal the pie, and vent the top with little cuts with a sharp knife.
- cook the pie at 350° for about 45 min. the apples should be very tender when poked with a knife. mmmmm
Pie Crust:
basic pie crust - 3 options:
crisco box recipe:
- 2 cups (500 ml) all purpose flour (i used unbleached organic)
- 1 tsp salt
- 3/4 cup crisco shortening (you can use vegan organic, no difference in taste) - COLD
- 4 - 8 tbsp ice water (must have ice in it)
- mix together dry ingredients.
- cut in cubes of COLD shortening with 2 knives or a pastry cutter. i often use 1/2 cup of shortening and roughly 1/4 cup (or a bit more) of very cold butter. i mix the shortening in first so that it has a mealy texture, then i cut in the butter, leaving larger pea sized lumps of butter. the pea sized crumbs of shortening in there is what makes it flaky. if you mash it too much, it will be tough. too little will make it hard to work with as the mix will be dry.
- sprinkle the water (i pretty much use 8 tbs or more) throughout the top of the dry dough coarse crumby looking stuff. do not stir, but gently mix it in with a fork (i use my hands, which are usually not very warm). stirring is supposed to be bad. i see if i can get it to form together into a ball after a minimum amount of kneading. work it as little as possible or it will get tough. if it won't stick together, sprinkle water on the dry crumbly parts.
once it forms into balls (round balls that you flatten a bit) you can wrap it in wax paper or plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 min or the next day. you should let it return to room temperature before rolling out. i rarely do this unless i have a lot of time. at best, i refrigerate it for 30 min and then let it warm up for 15 min while i do something else. at worst, i just roll it out straight from the mixing bowl. bad cook.
rolling out tips: julia child et al suggest plopping the dough down on a flour-sprinkled surface and sprinkling more flour on the dough before rolling, and then turning it 1/4 turn after every 2 or 3 rolls.
bah! that is so hard! i wish i could do that but i am always in a hurry and too lazy. one day i may try to be so professional. however, not today. i put down a piece of waxed paper, sprinkle some flour on it, plop down the dough, sprinkle some flour on that, and then lay another piece of waxed paper on top. i squish the dough down a bit, and start rolling in long, easy rolls, to ensure that the dough is rolled out to an even thickness. this is important! if the dough starts to crack and get weird shaped, i just lift up the waxed paper and squish it into the right shape with my fingers.
if i think the waxed paper will stick to the top of the dough, i will add more flour. if you think it will stick on the bottom, then flip the entire thing over before you to try to transfer it to the pie plate, and pull hte sticky bottom waxed paper off first, then flip it over onto the pie plate, and pull the freshly floured waxed paper off of the more troublesome (to take off) top side.
once in the pie plate, do not squish the dough into the bottom of the plate. this will cause shrinking once it is cooked, and will make you very sad. do not strech the dough at all. just kind of manoever it into position. treat the dough gently, and it will reward you.
if you are going to cook the dough before you add the filling, you must prick it with a fork...all over! let no inch go unpricked. some people add pie weights or beans to prevent the dough from bubbling, but the pricks always worked for me. snicker snicker.
here are some variations:
basic pie dough:
2 cups flour
1 tsp salt
2/3 cup chilled shortening
2 tbsp cold butter
4 tbsp ice water (i used 8)
you could also use 1/2 butter 1/2 shortening, which is hard to figure out....let see.....
1/4 cup = 4 tbsp
1/3 cup = 5 tbsp
1/2 cup = 8 tbsp
you could use 1/2 cup shortening and 1/4 cup butter
you could use 1/3 plus one tbsp of each
for this recipe, you incorporate the shortening into the flour first. make it resemble a course meal (crumby, but not bigger pea size crumbs). then, add the cubed COLD butter, and cut it in (this means use the pastry cutter or the 2 knives), so that it makes the big pea sized crumbs. keep the butter in the fridge until you are ready to add it. cold butter is harder to work in, so there is a better chance of success for flaky pastry.
the old school lard-converted recipe (this is actually really good, and easy to work)
2 cups flour
3/4 tsp salt
1 cup crisco
beat together: 1 egg
2 tbsp ice water
1 tbsp white vinegar
add the wet to the dry, and mix as you do the other recipes. mmmm.
